Digital Kitchen Food Scales: Etekcity vs Amazon Basics

We Analyzed 297,000+ Real Amazon Reviews

October 14, 2026


DonePick Score 9.2/10

DonePick Score 9.4/10

If you have shopped for digital kitchen food scales on Amazon lately, you have almost certainly seen the same two names sitting at the top of the bestseller list: the long-running Etekcity stainless-steel scale and the Amazon Basics Digital Kitchen Scale. Between them, these two budget scales have collected nearly 300,000 customer ratings — more real-world data than any marketing page could give you.

We read through the published customer reviews of both products (177,789 ratings for Etekcity, 119,560 for Amazon Basics, as of October 2026) and grouped the feedback into six dimensions that actually matter when you buy a scale. Here is what owners love, what they complain about, and which scale deserves a spot on your counter.

Quick Verdict

  • Overall satisfaction winner: Amazon Basics — 4.7 stars, with 82% five-star ratings, one of the highest satisfaction rates in the entire kitchen category.
  • Most battle-tested: Etekcity — a larger review base, more long-term use reports, and heavier praise density for build quality and value.
  • Both share the same #1 complaint: measurement drift. Neither scale is lab-grade; if you need sub-gram precision for coffee or medication, buy a dedicated milligram scale instead.

For everyday cooking, baking, and calorie tracking, both are safe buys under the Amazon return window — the differences below will decide which one fits you.

Etekcity vs Amazon Basics at a Glance

  • Star ratings: Amazon Basics averages 4.7 stars from 119,560 ratings, with 82% five-star. Etekcity averages 4.6 stars from 177,789 ratings, with 78% five-star.
  • Dissatisfaction share: only 2% of Amazon Basics ratings and 3% of Etekcity ratings are one-star — both sit well below typical kitchen-gadget failure rates.
  • Most-mentioned praise: build quality on both sides — 12,466 quality mentions on Etekcity and 3,686 on Amazon Basics.
  • Most-mentioned complaint: measurement accuracy — 6,169 mixed-sentiment mentions on Etekcity and 2,026 on Amazon Basics.
  • Batteries: included with both listings.
  • Price: both sell at budget prices that fluctuate with sales — check the current price on Amazon before buying.

1. Overall Satisfaction: Both Are Category Leaders, Amazon Basics Edges Ahead

The headline numbers are remarkably close. The Amazon Basics digital kitchen food scale averages 4.7 stars from 119,560 ratings, with 82% of buyers giving a perfect five. The Etekcity scale averages 4.6 stars from 177,789 ratings, with 78% five-star.

What stands out is how small the dissatisfaction is on both: only 2% one-star reviews for Amazon Basics and 3% for Etekcity. For context, most kitchen gadgets on Amazon cannot keep their one-star share under 5%. Whichever box arrives at your door, the overwhelming majority of owners have kept it on the counter.

2. Product Quality & Durability: Stainless Platforms That Take a Beating

Quality is the single most-mentioned positive theme for both scales — 12,466 mentions on Etekcity (roughly 1 in every 14 ratings) and 3,686 on Amazon Basics. Owners repeatedly call out the stainless-steel platform, the low-profile design, and the fact that these cheap scales do not feel cheap.

Durability stories split into two useful patterns:

  • Amazon Basics owners report drop resistance. One five-star reviewer joked that after “the sheer number of times I have accidentally dropped this scale, and it hasn’t broken, I figured it deserves one [review]… Worth the buy off of durability alone.”
  • Etekcity owners report multi-year service lives. A four-star reviewer wrote that it worked “great until it didn’t… now 3 years in, it hasn’t weighed properly in over two weeks” — meaning the scale served accurately for three years before dying, while the complaint was about aging, not build.

Reliability complaints exist on both sides: 2,410 Etekcity reviewers and 853 Amazon Basics reviewers mention units that stop working — with the Amazon Basics version skewing toward dead-on-arrival reports (“stopped working after one day”), while Etekcity complaints skew toward gradual failure after long use.

3. Ease of Use & Weighing Performance: Where the Complaints Actually Live

Accuracy is the most discussed theme in the review sections of both scales — 6,169 mentions on Etekcity (mixed sentiment: praised by most, questioned by some) and 2,026 on Amazon Basics. Read as a share of each product’s total ratings, Amazon Basics generates noticeably fewer accuracy complaints per review, which matches its higher star average.

What do owners praise day to day?

  • Tare function gets repeated applause on both: “the tare function makes it so easy to weigh ingredients without having to do extra math,” writes an Amazon Basics reviewer.
  • Display readability is a specific Amazon Basics strength — reviewers single out the “large, bright and very easy to read” display. Etekcity’s known ergonomic flaw: “Big bowls and plates block the display,” one owner notes, because the platform overhangs the screen.
  • Easy cleaning and compact storage are Etekcity’s most-cited lifestyle benefits: “compact enough that it doesn’t take up much counter space… incredibly easy to clean after use.”
  • Honest accuracy expectations. A thoughtful Etekcity five-star review captures the shared truth: readings can vary “a gram or so… within a few minutes. But the differences are not at all worrisome. If you are worried about a gram either way, this isn’t the right sort of scale for you.”

The practical takeaway from thousands of reviews: both scales are trustworthy to about ±1 g for cooking and baking, and an Amazon Basics reviewer’s warning — weight “can change sporadically” — is the reason calorie-counters occasionally re-tare before each ingredient.

4. Value for Money: The Reason These Two Win the Category

“Value for money” is the second most-mentioned positive theme on Etekcity (3,480 mentions) and third on Amazon Basics (1,724 mentions). Reviewers across both products use the same phrase unprompted: “for the price.” Both listings include batteries in the box, and both sell at pocket-change prices (check current prices on Amazon before buying — they fluctuate with sales).

The reviewer consensus is that at this price, you are not choosing between quality and cheapness — you are choosing which flavor of quality you prefer. A five-star Etekcity owner sums it up: “a great little scale… Definitely recommend it if you’re looking for something affordable, accurate, and easy to use.”

5. Packaging, Delivery & Setup Out of the Box

Packaging is almost absent from the complaint data on both products — a quiet signal in itself: out of nearly 297,000 ratings, unboxing damage or missing-parts horror stories do not form a theme. Both scales ship with batteries included, and setup is repeatedly described as “simple”: insert batteries, peel the protective film if present, place on a flat surface, and weigh. Amazon Basics reviewers specifically mention being up and running out of the box with no calibration ritual required.

Because both products fulfill through Amazon’s standard network, delivery speed and packaging protection track whatever FBA service level is shown on the listing at checkout — worth a glance during peak-season orders.

6. Customer Support Signals & Common Complaints to Watch

Neither product page generates a support-team narrative in reviews — the complaint energy goes to three concrete failure modes you should know before buying:

  1. Accuracy drift over time (both, more documented on Etekcity): readings creep off after a year or more of daily use. Fix-or-replace is the owner consensus; at this price most just rebuy.
  2. Early failures / DOA units (slightly more visible on Amazon Basics): “stopped working after one day” reports exist but are a thin minority (853 mentions across 119,560 ratings, ~0.7%). Buying through Amazon keeps the standard return window as your warranty.
  3. Not sub-gram capable (Etekcity): users trying to weigh yeast, supplements, or coffee to 0.1 g report frustration. These are 1 g-resolution cooking scales, not jeweler’s scales.

If your usage is “cook dinner, portion meals, weigh flour,” none of these are dealbreakers. If your usage is micro-precision, neither of these digital kitchen food scales is the right tool.

Which One Should You Buy?

Buy the Amazon Basics Digital Kitchen Scale if you want the highest-satisfaction, simplest option: brighter and larger display, fewer accuracy complaints per review, flat stainless platform that survives drops, and the peace of mind of Amazon’s own house brand. → Check today’s price on Amazon

Buy the Etekcity Multifunction Kitchen Scale if you want the proven workhorse with the deepest long-term data behind it: an enormous owner community, praised versatility across units, compact easy-clean design, and repeatedly cited value. Just keep large bowls off the display line. → Check today’s price on Amazon

Honestly? Review sentiment says the worst case on either is a ~$10 replacement in two years. Add one to your cart while it is in stock — both routinely sell out at their best prices.

FAQ

Which of the two digital kitchen food scales is more accurate?
Review data gives Amazon Basics a slightly cleaner accuracy record (2,026 accuracy mentions across 119,560 ratings vs 6,169 mixed mentions across Etekcity’s 177,789 ratings). Both resolve to about 1 gram; neither is suitable for sub-gram work.

Do these scales come with batteries?
Yes — both product listings state that batteries are included, and reviewers confirm the scales work out of the box.

Is the Etekcity kitchen scale good for baking?
Yes. Bakers form a large share of its 177,789 ratings, and reviews praise consistent readings, the tare function for multi-ingredient mixing bowls, and easy cleanup. Long-term drift after 1–3 years of heavy use is the most common negative baking-related note.

Can I use these scales for calorie counting or meal prep?
Yes — reviewers frequently mention portion tracking. The practical tip from owners is to re-tare before each ingredient, since both scales can show small reading fluctuations.

Are these the best-selling kitchen scales on Amazon?
They are the #1 and #2 items in Amazon’s kitchen scale bestseller list at the time of writing (October 2026), with 177,789 and 119,560 global ratings respectively.

Related Posts

You May Also Like

Discover carefully selected products, detailed comparisons, seasonal recommendations, and practical insights to help you make smarter buying decisions.